Predictive Maintenance 4.0 - Practical IoT Intro for Vehicles & Machinery

Predictive-Maintenance-4

Predictive maintenance (PdM) is all the jazz right now.

And for good reason:

The rise of Big Data, IoT, Cloud and AI is driving PdM with a 40% CAGR towards $10+ bn by 2022.

And the hype is real.

As evident below, Google Trends shows a 400%+ increase in interest since 2008:

Predictive Maintenance Growth Trend

Yet, with the hype also comes a ton of fluff & buzz articles.

In this article, we cut the clutter with a simple guide to PdM - with focus on CAN bus applications (vehicles & machines).

In particular, we outline what predictive maintenance is, how it works and why it’s attractive.

We end with practical examples and actionable next steps - so that you can stop reading and actually start a pilot.

Enjoy!

Predictive Maintenance Industrial Automation

WHAT IS PREDICTIVE MAINTENANCE, REALLY?

Let’s start with a really basic definition:

The goal of predictive maintenance
is to forecast & prevent equipment failure

Too generic?

Let’s try and put it in the context of two classic maintenance methods:

Reactive-Preventive-Predictive-Maintenance-Types

Of course, predictive maintenance can be further split into sub sections - see details below:

Predictive Maintenance 1.0 to 4.0 - Details

In principle, predictive maintenance has been around for ages: When a technician inspects an asset and makes a change to avoid future failure, that’s predictive maintenance.

The difference is the amount of data that is used and the frequency of updates - cf. the overview of PdM 1.0-4.0.

Below, we focus mainly on Predictive Maintenance 4.0, using IoT, big data and predictive analytics in near real-time.

In particular, we'll dive into the sub sections of PdM 4.0 to show that this is still an extremely broad segmentation.

Predictive-Maintenance-Levels-Sophistication-1.0-2.0-3.0-4.0



On the surface, predictive maintenance is kind of simple.

Yet, in a 2017 survey of 280 companies PwC found that only 11% have reached “PdM 4.0” maturity (i.e. using big data to do predictive analytics) - though 47% plan to implement it in the future.

Predictive Maintenance Survey Companies Examples Results

That’s a big disconnect!

If PdM is simple, then why haven’t more companies already implemented it?

Let’s explore this below.




HOW DOES PREDICTIVE MAINTENANCE WORK?

You can look at predictive maintenance as a process flow with 3 steps - as illustrated below:

Predictive Maintenance Process Flow Collect Predict React

1# COLLECT: First, you’ll need to gather relevant data that can help you predict time-to-failure. This is often done by e.g. adding vibration IoT sensors to get “indirect” data.

However, a far more direct method is to tap into the run-time data the machine uses to operate. All vehicles - and most industrial machinery - operate using a combination of transducers (sensors and actuators) and control units. The control units implement algorithms that determine the behavior of the machine. The run-time data is continuously transported, often using wires and communication protocols.

One very popular transportation method is "CAN bus", whihch is e.g. standard in all vehicles. If a vehicle or machine uses CAN bus wires for data transportation, it's often possible to safely tap directly into the run-time data stream. This can be done using an IoT CAN bus data logger, which opens up the full scope of your asset operational data. Your CAN logger can then transfer this data to the cloud via a WiFi hotspot (WLAN, 3G, 4G) in near real-time.

2# PREDICT: The collected data is processed in the cloud. For CAN bus data, this includes transforming the data to scaled engineering values. Once ready, the data can be used in a predictive model. These range from simplistic single-variable thresholds - to advanced machine learning algorithms. More on this below.

3# REACT: The model provides estimates of e.g. the time-to-failure for an asset and its components. From here, it’s “simply” reacting on the insight: Auto-schedule maintenance, send push notifications to warn staff of potential breakdowns and optimize your spare part inventory.





PRACTICAL PREDICTION MODEL EXAMPLES

Do you feel the PREDICT step is a bit fuzzy? You’re not alone!

Below we try and flesh this out with some very basic illustrative examples:

Example 1# - The Oil-Sensitive Truck: In this Google Sheets illustrative example we consider a vehicle where the only possible failure is from not refilling the oil. Over time, the oil level decreases to 10% and the vehicle breaks down - its ‘Remaining Useful Life’ (RUL) is zero. In the example, we pretend that we observe the true RUL and adapt a simple linear regression. With this we predict the RUL out-of-sample and decide a time for warning - which in the example is ~17% off vs. the true RUL.

The point here is merely to show the concept in a simple way - feel free to copy & try it out yourself!

Predictive Maintenance Truck Example Oil Vehicle Practical Simple

Example 2# - NASA Turbofan Engine: We strongly recommend reading this great practical intro by Ben Everson. In short, he takes outset in NASA’s 2008 Turbofan Engine Degradation simulation data set), which contains training & test data on 10 engines equipped with 20+ sensors. The goal is similar to Example 1#, but in a more realistic context. In particular, this is helpful if you're about to get started with the basic data cleaning & statistical considerations.

Check out both his intro and follow-up!



The above examples illustrate that adding more data quickly adds complexity.

For this reason, PdM using machine learning (ML) has become popular in predictive models.

Machine learning is a natural fit as PdM involves failure classification using huge amounts of sensor data. We won’t dive deeper into PdM using machine learning here, but consider reading this InfoQ technical intro or this Azure AI article using the NASA Turbofan data with ML.

Further, if you’re interested in a bit more detail on the predictive models for PdM, check out this article by BigData Republic - it’s a great read, in particular to provide context for the RUL modelling strategy in our examples 1# and 2# above.

We’ll detail how to get started further below - but first we’ll look at the potential benefits of PdM:


Predictive Maintenance AI Machine Learning Artificial Intelligence


Predictive Maintenance Benefits Vehicles

IMPACT & BENEFITS OF PREDICTIVE MAINTENANCE

If you succeed with PdM, it can be game changing - with examples of impact statistics including:

Predictive Maintenance Impact Financials Breakdowns Percentage

Source 1: 30-50% | Source 2: 10-20% | Source 3: 70%


Below we detail some of the major benefits:

CAN Bus Opportunities Remote Troubleshooting KPI Dashboards

GO BEYOND: Finally, basing your PdM on "direct data" is far more powerful than e.g. using vibration sensors. With CAN bus data, you’ll practically have a digital copy of your asset in the cloud - opening up tons of new applications: Productivity optimization, remote troubleshooting, real-time KPI dashboards and more. In turn, this improves the return-on-investment (ROI) on your implementation.


The benefits can be harvested by both end users (e.g. site or fleet managers) and original equipment manufacturers (OEMs).

Furter, PdM is highly relevant across both heavy duty vehicle fleets (trucks, buses), defense vehicles, agricultural equipment, industrial production machinery, battery management - and many more industries.

In short: With predictive maintenance, the sky’s the limit!

But of course it’s not that easy - in particular, five major challenges come into play:


Five Key Challenges in Implementing Predictive Maintenance


  1. Changing your culture - PdM is unknown territory to most corporate leaders. “Will this work?”, “Does it kill our budget?” - get buy-in (or do light PoCs under the radar)

  2. Choosing the right IoT solution - the market is complex and finding a good fit is hard. If you’re just getting started with PdM, avoid an expensive enterprise solution. Start small

  3. Managing big data - processing big data can be difficult. Set the right team and begin with few parameters. But: Historical data is vital - so store all relevant data you can

  4. Avoiding data lock-in - most IoT solutions lock your data in the their cloud. However, this data and the capabilities learned may become your top differentiators. Own your solution

  5. Building your model - the model should match your capabilities. Don’t choose a big outsourced model you don't understand if it’s not a fit. Start simple

The challenges are significant - and implementing PdM requires the right approach.

Challenges & Problems In Implementing Predictive Maintenance


So how do you get started?

We explore this in our next section!

 

CL3000 CAN Bus IoT Device

STEP-BY-STEP: GET STARTED WITH PREDICTIVE MAINTENANCE

Back to the question:

Why have so few corporates implemented predictive maintenance?

From our experience, the answer is pretty simple:

Too much talk. Too little action.

PdM gets plenty of hype even at the top - but dies because nobody get started.

So how do you do it?

The key is to do a small, simple and low cost proof-of-concept (PoC)
- that scales easily

Why? When you bring the PoC to your management team, you drastically reduce the need for them to “believe”.

Instead they can see. This opens up the budgets for scaling - so you can move to the next phase.

To do a PoC for predictive maintenance, our advice is to follow the below steps:



CHEAT SHEET: PREDICTIVE MAINTENANCE PROOF OF CONCEPT


Identify Pain Point PdM

1# Identify a well-known pain point - is Machine X at Site Y a well-known problem child? Then that’s a good place to start. If the machine operates on CAN bus, it’s a great candidate for your PdM PoC

Strong Predictive Maintenance Team Developer Coder

2# Set your team - fully dedicate a 3-4 person team to implement the PoC over 3-6 months. Ideally get an application expert, data expert, coder and a communicator (to sell results internally)

Define Predictive Model

3# Define your predictive model - identify what failure type you’ll predict, what the failure process looks like (fast, slow, …), how you’ll predict it and what data is required

IIoT IoT CAN Bus Data Logger Predictive Maintenance

4# Acquire 1-10 simple-to-use IoT data loggers - ideally limit spending to 500-4000€ max. Check with the supplier that the loggers are able to record data from your application if in doubt

Collect CAN Data in Cloud

5# Collect all relevant data to your cloud - connect the IoT CAN loggers to your asset and a WiFi hotspot to set up the transfer to your cloud server. Start building your data processing scripts

Train PdM Model ML Dataset In-Sample

6# “Train” your predictive model - as you get historical data (incl. failure data), you can adapt your model parameters to improve your model’s ability to forecast out-of-sample failure

PdM Model Start Production Mode

7# Move your PdM model from “development” to “production” - with your trained model, you can now actually start monitoring if your model is able to identify unexpected issues early on

PdM Reaction Engine Push Notification SMS

8# Add reaction engine - to “sell” the PoC to management, we recommend incorporating simple auto-reactions - e.g. sending an SMS to a site manager when an issue is identified

Scale Up Solution for PdM

9# “Sell”, develop & scale - present the PoC, results and a business case / roadmap for scaling it up. The purpose is to get management on-board to provide funding for the next phase



Note two subtle points:

First, you ideally need (a lot of) regular data & failure data to train your predictive model - so get started ASAP.

  • Further, make sure to take the “data gathering period” into account in your planning
  • Alternatively, you can invest in more devices to speed things up if you have the budget (and enough identical assets)

Second, it’s vital that you don’t drop the ball during step 9#:

  • Avoid over-promising in your business case and demanding absurd budgets
  • Avoid trying to implement PdM across everything in year one
  • Avoid shifting your PoC model to an advanced machine learning model day 1 (even if your CEO says so)

You need to match expectations vs. capabilities and take your time.

This is also why you benefit from a zero-subscription solution where you own the data. This way you avoid a continuous cash-drain (i.e. time pressure) and you have the basis for developing in-house digital capabilities and a custom-fit platform.




NEXT STEPS: CHOOSE AN IOT LOGGER

As mentioned, you’ll want to start data collection asap - hence you need an IoT data logger, e.g. the CL3000:


CL3000: Low Cost IoT CAN Bus Data Logger

If you aim to use CAN bus data as your basis, we strongly recommend the CL3000 CAN bus data logger with WiFi. This device has a number of advantages for predictive maintenance:

+

Low Cost & Unlocked - The CL3000 costs only 399 EUR/unit with free software, free shipping and no subscription fees. This is lowest cost IoT CAN logger available - perfect for getting started and scaling up 

+

Plug & Play - Simply connect the CL3000 and it’ll start recording data to the SD card. Further, you can configure it to send this via a WiFi hotspot to your FTP cloud server in less than 5 minutes

+

Easily Transfer Data - Once connected, the logger will simply push log files to your server in e.g. 1 MB chunks - ready for being auto-converted to readable form by our free software CANvas

+

Supports J1939, CANopen & More - The CL3000 works on all high-speed CAN bus systems, incl. J1939 (e.g. trucks, buses, cranes, excavators, …), OBD2 and CANopen (e.g. production machinery)

Want to know more? Read our detailed intro to the CL3000


"What impressed me most was the responsive and helpful support of CSS:
They really listen to their customers, suggestions for improvements were heard!"

- Harald H, B-sab GmbH


We hope you found this article useful!

At CSS, we love working with our end users - and we’d be happy to spar with you to find an ideal solution!

Send us a mail and we’ll get back to you asap!


Liked this article? Please share!




RECOMMENDED FOR YOU



This site uses cookies to enhance your experience - for more info, see our privacy policy

OK!